That just wouldn't make any sense, since dead people don't have babies. It is obvious from the various positions of theologians throughout the ages that there is no firm doctrinal statement on whether or not Mary experienced "any" pain in birthing the Christ. No one can say anything greater of her, though he had as many tongues as there are leaves on the trees. This page was last edited on 5 May , at The use of the word "brother" in Scripture is, in addition, not only used to refer to biological brothers but also to relatives Genesis The Assumption had been a part of the Church's spiritual and doctrinal patrimony for centuries.
Perpetual virginity of Mary
The Catechism begins this section on Mary by inviting us to see her through the eyes of Saint Luke. This is consistent with his lifelong acceptance of the idea of the perpetual virginity of Mary. But Harnack seems to have foreseen this theory before it was proposed by Wellhausen; for he showed that the two chapters in question belonged to the author of the third Gospel and of the Acts . Calvin even mocked the 4th century doubter saying, "Helvidius has shown himself too ignorant, in saying that Mary had several sons" qtd. Hence he believes that the idea had found its way among the Jews in pre-Christian times, so that the Judaism which flowed directly into early Christianity had undergone a certain amount of syncretism. Maybe they were His siblings, maybe they weren't; to be honest, the question of whether Mary had given birth to them or not never really crossed my mind.
Mary - Perpetual Virginity
Interestingly enough, that is precisely what the Catholic Church teaches and has taught since the very beginning: For by such added names the positive proofs of merit are apparent. Prayer, however, must be John Chrysostom — defended perpetual virginity on a number of grounds, one of which was Jesus' commands to his mother in Calvary: Why do you wonder at this, O man? Medicine Chest Against All Heresies
Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Fausset , David Brown. James suggests the reference to children refers to the children of St. That certainly would have settled the issue. Jaroslav Pelikan, Concordia, ].